UPDATED: Orders Closed! Holiday Dessert Order Menu

Due to an overwhelmingly supportive and generous response to the menu, I am at maximum capacity for this one person show! I am no longer taking orders for this weekend's holiday delivery and thank you very much to those that were so quick to fill up my order sheet! If you didn't get an order in, don't fret! My online bake shop will be in effect at the beginning of the year. Thank you all and happiest of holidays! See you in 2013!! Hi all! Please see below for the menu and ordering info! I will have two centralized pick up locations this Sunday, December 23rd. Developing the online bakeshop has been met with several frustrating bumps in the road and it looks like it won't launch until the New Year. BUT, not being one to have my dreams squelched easily, I've drawn up a sort of "best of" list of many people's favorites. All info needed to order is included below. Thanks and have the happiest of Holidays!


2012 Winter Holiday Sweets and Treats and Breads Menu

COOKIES (all cookies sold by the dozen, prices vary):                  

Double Chocolate Maldon Sea Salt Shorts             15/dz

Chocolate Peppermint Shortbread                          12/dz

Breadcrumb Shortbread                                          12/dz

Lemon Cornmeal                                                      12/dz    

Oatmeal Crisps                                                         10/dz

Raspberry Rugelach                                                 17/dz    

Chocolate & Cocoa Nib Rugelach                            17/dz

Pecan Sandies                                                          10/dz

Pies and Crostatas: 

Nutmeg Custard Pie        17-

Buttermilk Chess Pie      17-

Chocolate Walnut            20-

Shaker Meyer Lemon      20-

Roasted Orange and Almond Cream Crostata    20-

Roasted Pear, Vanilla Bean and Honey Crostata   20-

Breads and Breakfast Items:

Cinnamon Rolls (can be delivered prebaked/frozen for you to prepare Christmas morning): 10-/8servings      

Vanilla Roasted Pear and Almond Cream Feuilletes (puff pastry): 18-/8servings                                                                                                                                                

Cast Iron Biscuits (can be delivered prebaked/frozen for you to prepare at your convenience): 10/8                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      

Monkey Bread (pecans, brioche dough, delicious: our family Christmas tradition): 15/Whole 9” Round

Pannetone: 18/whole


Christmas Rum Cake (using Prichard’s Fine Rum): 25-

Double Chocolate Farmhouse Cake: 40-/8” double layer

Carrot Cake: 30-/8”double layer

Lemon Mascarpone Cream: 40-/8”double layer

Caramel Cream Apple Spice Cake: 35-/8”double layer

Seasonal Ice Creams (all 7-/pint):

Salted Caramel

Eggnog Custard


Mint Chocolate Chip

Salted Caramel w. Coffee Cocoa Nib Chip

Vanilla Bean and Rum

Milk Chocolate


All orders must be placed by Friday, December  21st for a Sunday, December 23rd delivery. All home deliveries will have an additional $5 charge added to the final order cost. There will be alternate and centralized pick up locations offered as well as delivery. Please order by listing the quantities of each item you’d like and whether or not you would prefer to pick up at a central location or to have it delivered to your home.

Place orders here: buttermilkroadsundaysupper@gmail.com

Prices listed are including tax.

If you have any further questions, do not hesitate to contact Lisa at the above email address.

Thank you and happiest of holidays!